“Yeah, I hit 1.000,” Chisenhall said with a slight laugh.
It was a sixth-inning single off White Sox lefty Charlie Leesman on Sept. 14 in Chicago. Prior to that, Chisenhall hadn’t faced a lefty since Aug. 8. Before that, his last at-bat against a left-hander fell on July 19. Do you see the pattern here? With the Indians in the postseason chase, manager Terry Francona put Chisenhall’s development aside and utilized him primarily as an against-righties option to squeeze the most out of his bat.
Bring up Chisenhall’s history against lefties, and Francona expresses confidence.
“I’m sure he can [handle left-handers]. He’s a good hitter. He has bat speed,” Francona said. “Sometimes you have to grow into it. Sometimes you have to, before you really get the opportunity, or a fair opportunity, sometimes it comes in increments. That’s a balance that’s sometimes hard. It tugs at me a little bit.
“You’ve got a young kid that’s talented. Last year, you’re trying to work him in, but then you have [Mike] Aviles sitting over there and you’re in a playoff hunt. So you try to strike that balance. Sometimes it’s difficult.”
Chisenhall’s monthly at-bat splits against lefties looked like this last season:
Chisenhall dealt with a demotion to Triple-A between May and June, but after he hit .095 off lefties in April, it became clear how Francona was going to use the third baseman. On the season, Chisenhall hit just .111 (4-for-36) off southpaws, dropping his career mark to .194 (.612 OPS) in 124 at-bats. Against righties, he’s hit .256 (.714 OPS) in 519 career at-bats.
“It’s just different,” Chisenhall said, “because coming up through the Minors you get every at-bat and then, once you get to the Majors, it’s about winning. No more development. You have to be ready to play.”
Chisenhall understands what he is up against this spring. Competition is no stranger to the third baseman, but this spring’s situation is different. Cleveland has pulled Carlos Santana out from behind the plate and is giving him a look at third. Maybe Santana can develop into the everyday option (he’s certainly looked comfortable and competent so far), or perhaps the switch hitter will prove to be an option there against tough left-handers.
One of Francona’s skills — one that was on display all season during the Tribe’s run to the playoffs in ’13 — is using players in a way to maximize their abilities. He understands Chisenhall’s career shortcomings against lefties and, while more development might be needed there, knows the third baseman can do damage against righties. Consider September, when Chisenhall had that one at-bat against a left-hander, but posted a strong .270/.325/.595 slash line in he final month.
It is possible that the same kind of role awaits Chisenhall come Opening Day, or it’s possible that he wins the third-base job outright if the Santana experiment ultimately flops. Or, Cleveland might send Chisenhall down to the Minors to get the everyday at-bats in order to focus on development. No matter the final decision, Francona said all he offered Chisenhall in their pre-camp one-on-one meeting was the truth.
“We told Lonnie the truth in our meeting,” Francona said. “We believe we’re a better team with him on it. But we want him to earn it. That’s being very truthful and I think he agrees with it.”
Chisenhall said he’s been delivered the same message each spring.
“There have been more bumps in the the road than I have wanted,” Chisenhall said early in camp. “But, I’m still young. I know what I can do for the Cleveland Indians, and I know what I can do at third base.”
Photos from the past couple days
Catch up on camp with these links:
- Read about the Indians’ signing of Justin Masterson to a one-year deal to avoid arbitration
- Check out this feature on Asdrubal Cabrera and his desire to do more this year
- Read why the Indians don’t think too much has changed, even with higher expectations
- Nick Swisher says being “Mr. Mom” helped his shoulder heal over winter
- Cody Allen was ready to close, but is perfectly fine with his setup role
- Does versatile Elliot Johnson have inside track for a bench job?
- The Indians had to slow an eager Shaun Marcum down at start of camp
- Read why GM Chris Antonetti is happy with the Draft-pick compensation for Ubaldo
- Francona says not to be surprised if some NRIs make the Opening Day roster
The Indians and Masterson have reached a deal on a one-year contract worth $9,762,500, avoiding arbitration. Te big right-hander will be able to skip the four-hour flight to St. Petersburg, where he was scheduled to have an arbitration hearing on Thursday.
“I’m here for this season, man,” Masterson said before leaving the clubhouse.
During Tuesday’s morning workout, Masterson threw off a mound in a bullpen session with general manager Chris Antonetti looking on. Assistant general manager Mike Chernoff, who had been slated to fly to Florida to help argue the Tribe’s case, was also on hand at the facility. Antonetti has maintained all along that the Indians hoped to avoid a hearing.
Through the arbitration process, Masterson is seeking $11.8 million, while the Indians had countered with $8.05 million. The agreed upon contract falls just short of the midpoint, which was $9.925 million.
Over the winter, and again in the past few days, Masterson’s camp also tossed out ideas for a long-term extension. Right now, though, the two sides are concentrating on a one-year pact to avoid arbitration with the plan of potentially rekindling long-term talks later this spring or this season.
Masterson is eligible for free agency next offseason.
“We’ve got plenty of time to work on anything like that,” Masterson said. “It’s just working through it, what the value is, what’s reasonable pay, how things work. It’s a different system, especially when you’ve got to be really smart about how you move your money around and you want to make sure you’re making a good investment.
“You’ve got to truly believe in the guy. Not that they don’t truly believe in me, but it’s what you’re working through in that process. It’s easy for us when it’s not our money to throw it around and say, ‘Just do this.’ When it’s your own money, you say, ‘ I think we’re going to think about this a little bit more.’ It doesn’t bother me.”
Masterson, who will turn 29 years old in March, went 14-10 with a 3.45 ERA in 193 innings for the Indians last season. The sinkerballer made his first American League All-Star team and ended the season with a team-high 195 strikeouts. He has gone 44-55 with a 4.08 ERA in parts of five seasons with Cleveland.
Spring Training has been underway for about a week now, but things finally felt official on Monday. Everybody was on hand and moving between the fields for Cleveland’s first full-squad workout of the year.
All morning, plenty of laughter could be heard around the complex.
“I missed these guys, man,” Indians manager Terry Francona said. “I was so happy to be back.”
It seemed fitting that the real Day 1 coincided with the news that Ubaldo Jimenez agreed to a four-year contract with the Orioles. Will the Indians miss him, too? There is no denying Big U’s impact on Cleveland’s run to the Wild Card last season, that’s for sure.
It’s an old cliche, but only time will tell if the loss of Jimenez crushes the Tribe’s chances of returning to the playoffs. The double-whammy of losing both him and Scott Kazmir is a blow to the Indians’ rotation, no doubt. But were they worth the kind of deals they signed with Baltimore and Oakland, respectively?
Maybe you disagree with me, and that’s fine, but I completely understand why the Indians passed.
It was a miracle that Kazmir went through his renaissance in 2013, after being out of affiliated ball a year earlier. The lefty himself often joked that he led the league in medical mound visits. Two years for a guaranteed $22 million. I wish Kazmir well, but that’s all kinds of risk. No thanks.
As for Jimenez, let’s not forget that one year ago, many Indians fans wanted him out of the rotation and kicked to the curb that Kazmir came from. Let’s also forget that, with the exception of the first two and a half months in 2010 and the final five months in 2013, Jimenez was a mostly wreck for the past four seasons. Consider that the righty had a 5.03 ERA with a 1.46 WHIP in the 502.1 IP between June 23, 2010-April 21, 2013. In the other 267 IP in the 2010/2013 seasons, Ubaldo had a 2.06 ERA and a 1.19 WHIP.
Maybe you’ll call that cherry picking. I call it mediocre performance 65 percent of the time over a four-year period. Granted, the other 35 percent was steller, but was that worth a reported $50 million over four years? I’m not sure, and I’m not sure a team in Cleveland’s position can afford that kind of risk.
For now, Cleveland will hope that Danny Salazar can give them around the same or more than what Kazmir provided. Corey Kluber, if his 2013 was any indication, seems to have the potential to provide the kind of innings Jimenez gave the Indians (and with fewer walks). In the short-term, having Jimenez would’ve shored up the staff, rendered this spring’s fifth spot competition moot, but “short-term” wasn’t in the cards.
Photos from the past few days
More from Indians.com…
- For Presidents Day, I did a Q&A with Indians team president Mark Shapiro.
- Francona wrote a letter to Indians fans.
- Monday’s notes: Jason Giambi, Carlos Santana at 3B and more.
- Feature on Salazar, who will be critical to the rotation.
- Sunday’s notes: Stuff on Aaron Harang, Frank Herrmann and more.
- Saturday’s notes: Stuff on Josh Tomlin, Ryan Rabun and more.
- Feature on Justin Masterson, who is looking to avoid an arbitration hearing.
Stay tuned for more…
Francona didn’t quite ask Masterson to “Be Mine” on Valentine’s Day, but the manager’s affection is apparent.
“For however long I’m here, I hope he’s here,” Francona said on Friday. “I think everybody feels that way. And Masty knows that. I’d be shocked if you asked Masty if he felt like he was respected here, if he said no.
“It’s just the economics of the game. That’s a side of it that’s difficult and I’m glad I don’t have to deal with it.”
As has been well-documented, Masterson is eligible for arbitration this year in what is his last season prior to free-agent eligibility. That being the case, both the pitcher and the team have expressed an interest in a long-term deal. That said, talks have stalled and the focus right now is in Masterson’s 2014 contract.
If needed, Cleveland has a hearing scheduled for Thursday. If no settlement is reached before going before an arbitration panel, Masterson’s salary will either be $11.8 million (his request) or $8.05 million (Cleveland’s offer). GM Chris Antonetti would love nothing more than to avoid another hearing.
“I’ll always be optimistic,” Antonetti said. “We’re going to continue to negotiate with Justin. Again, our clear preference would be to negotiate an agreement. Hopefully, that’s possible in his case. If it’s not, there’s a mechanism in place to resolve it.”
Masterson’s situation is a tricky one, considering the current free-agent climate. If no extension is reached before next offseason (the pitcher said earlier this week that he’s willing to negotiation in-season, if necessary), a qualifying offer could come into play. If Masterson has an outstanding season, or even just a decent season, it’s a safe bet that Cleveland would offer the sinkerballer a one-year qualifying offer for 2015 in order to secure Draft-pick compensation.
There is always the chance that Masterson will pitch well enough to decline such an offer and net a lucrative long-term deal on the open market. Or, there is the possibility that he winds up in a situation like free-agents Ervin Santana and Ubaldo Jimenez, two solid rotation arms that remain unsigned due to their attachment to Draft compensation. Masterson could accept a qualifying offer and have another platform year, or he could risk twisting in the wind by turning down such a deal.
What’s great for Cleveland is that, if any pitcher could handle such uncertainty hanging over their head, it’s the easygoing Masterson. This is, after all, the guy who will joke about his beard (or lack thereof) throwing off his mechanics after a bad outing, or bring up the positives of his wife’s cookie business after a tough loss. He knows some people are critical of his extremely happy-go-lucky personality, but it can certainly help keep his contract status from being a distraction.
“It doesn’t bother me at all,” said Masterson, flashing his typical smile.
The Indians believe that is the case, too.
“He’s a pretty special kid. That’s the way he is,” Francona said. “He’s actually been that way since the day I met him, and I’m sure he was like that before I met him.”
Photo of the Day
Indians second baseman Jason Kipnis was buried in a heap of Twitter criticism after I posted an unflattering photo of him on Thursday. I can confirm that Kipnis is in great shape this spring, and he wanted to make sure everyone else knew it, too. During the workout today, he flexed for the camera as a message to any doubters.
Other items from Friday…
- The Indians had an arbitration hearing with pitcher Josh Tomlin on Friday. The right-hander was seeking $975,000 and the Indians offered $800,000. A decision on the pitcher’s 2014 salary is expected to arrive on Saturday. Tomlin spent most of last season coming back from Tommy John surgery and is a fifth-starter candidate this spring.
- Lefty reliever Josh Outman had a gut feeling he was about to be traded this offseason when he received an out-of-nowhere phone call from a member of the Rockies training staff. The same thing happened two winters earlier, and he was traded the next day by the A’s. Check on Friday’s notebook for more on Outman’s reaction to joining the Tribe.
- It’s only one mound session, but Francona said Trevor Bauer looked like a new pitcher. The manager said the difference was “night and day” compared to last year. More on this in the notebook, too.
- Also on Indians.com on Friday, a feature on Indians right-hander Danny Salazar, who will play an integral role this year.
- Francona was saddened to learn of the passing of Jim Fregosi on Friday morning. In 1997, Francona followed Fregosi as manager of the Phillies. Said Tito: “Anybody that’s been in a room with him, you can’t help but hear him. He just carried on conversations and was just so full of life. It’s not a very good way to start the morning when you come in and see that. … I know when I got to Philly, the veterans that were there loved him.”
- Position players are not required to report until Saturday, but Brohio is open for business in Arizona. Nick Swisher popped into the complex, and made sure to announce, “I’m here!” Physicals for position players are Sunday and the first full-squad workout is set for Monday.
- Francona has emphasized that the last thing he’s doing right now is evaluating pitchers during these early mound sessions: “We told those guys, specifically, yesterday, ‘When you see us walk behind the mound, we’re not evaluating. You’re getting your legs under you, you’re building your arm strength and you’re working on your mechanics.’”
- Francona said Minor League right-hander Bryan Price (right hamstring) was held out of Friday’s workout, but might be cleared to return to the field by Saturday. It’s a minor injury.
- On Feb. 25, Francona and a few staff members will attend a meeting on the new instant replay rules that go into effect this season. As for the home-plate collisions rule change, the manager hopes a decision comes soon: “It’s got to be soon. I know they’re havng a tough time with the language of the rule, which I understand. That’s part of why I was in favor of not having it. You would hope that it would be soon. It’s going to be different. In Spring Training, you don’t want somebody getting killed at the plate anyway, but if there’s going to be a rule change, you’d like to certainly be aware of it and stay ahead of it.”
Stay tuned for more…
Indians general manager Chris Antonetti was asked how much he enjoyed the first real day of Spring Training.
“I’d much prefer to be in 5-degree weather and shoveling snow in my driveway,” Antonetti quipped. “No, it’s always a great day to have that first workout and have guys out there throwing and some guys out there hitting. It’s an exciting day.”
At this time, I’d like to issue a formal apology to anyone back home is actually is braving the 5-degree weather and shoveling the snow in their driveway. I won’t bother you with any lines about how sunny it is here. Oh, wait. First sentence above. Whoops!
Many of Cleveland’s arms went through mound sessions. That included Trevor Bauer, Justin Masterson, John Axford and C.C. Lee (in the photo to the side). Those who weren’t throwing off the bump were on one of the practice diamonds working on fielding drills.
Position players are not required to report until Saturday. Their physicals are Sunday and the first full-squad workout is slated for Monday. There are a handful of players who are not in camp yet, but Indians manager Terry Francona made it clear that he’s not keeping score.
“It’s not a test. There’s enough trust built already. Guys know what to do,” Francona said. “If they’re here, great. It’s fun to see them. It’s a relaxed atmosphere where they can get their work done. The guys that aren’t here, that doesn’t mean they’re not working. Jason Giambi, he doesn’t need to be here. Guys know what they need to do.”
After all, reporting one day earlier isn’t going to win the World Series.
Photo of the Day
Indians shortstop Asdrubal Cabrera watches his son, Meyer, fielding a grounder on Thursday.
Some notes from Tribe camp….
- The Indians formally announced their four-year contract extension with left fielder Michael Brantley and held a press conference on Thursday. Check out Brantley’s comments, the details of the deal and more on Indians.com.
- In case you missed it: here is Wednesday’s feature on Carlos Santana’s plan to work on third base this spring. On Thursday, and for the next few days, he’ll work as a catcher before joining the infielders next week.
- Lefty Nick Hagadone said he’s happy to have his grievance in the past and he’s looking forward to competing for a bullpen spot this spring. Hagadone said he’s widened the stance of his delivery and is working on having a better tempo, all with the idea of improving his walk rate. The changes were made after discussing it with pitching coach Mickey Callaway after last season.
- Francona said right-hander Bryan Price, a Minor League reliever who was added to the 40-man roster over the winter, tweaked a hamstring during drills on Thursday. It didn’t sound serious, but we’ll have more information on Friday.
- Antonetti was asked if the Indians might have a Michael Bourn-esque acqusition in the works for this spring. Here’s the GM’s reply: “We’re continuing to look for ways to improve the team, wherever those opportunities might be,” Antonetti said. “But I really do feel good about the group we have in camp. I feel like we have what we need to contend for the Central and earn a postseason berth, and hopefully compete for a World Series.”
- Francona, who managed plenty of games against Derek Jeter in the AL East, raved about the shortstop one day after it was announced that this would be his final season: “If you’re a baseball fan, he is the walking example of what’s good in baseball. You respect him so much, and yet you want him to have as little to do with the outcome of a game if you’re his opponent. That’s probably the biggest compliment you can give him. He’s going to find a way to beat you, whether it’s on the bases, on defense or at the plate. And, again, because I was in that division, I saw it too much. He ranks right up there with the most respected players. I’m glad he’s walking away on his own terms. We’ll probably get to see him seven times this year. I hope he goes 0-for-28 and we give him a nice plaque or something.”
- The Indians are doing their part in trying to help save the Bob Feller Museum in Van Meter, Iowa. The museum, which has closed its doors during the winter to save money, is working with the team on possibly sending some items to Cleveland. “Bob Feller was the engine that powered the museum,” said Bob DiBiasio, the Indians’ senior vice president of public affairs. “Unfortunately, since his passing the business model for the Bob Feller Museum has not been working. As we move forward, our primary objective is to foster Mr. Feller’s legacy in the two places he called home, Van Meter, Iowa, and Cleveland.”
- The Indians will go to an arbitration hearing with pitcher Josh Tomlin on Friday. He’s seeking $975,000 and the Indians are offering $800,000. Said Antonetti: “Our clear preference is to always negotiate a settlement. And I think we have a very long track record of demonstrating that and trying to do it. But it has to be an equitable settlement and one we think makes sense. In both Vinnie and Josh’s case, we felt we made very earnest efforts to try and reach an agreement. Unfortunately, we weren’t able to. So, at this point, the arbitrators can decide and then we can move on. I think that’s the most important thing. We can get it behind us and move on. Weve now done it with Vinnie. It’s in the past. And as of Saturday, it’ll be in the past for Josh as well.”
More from Goodyear on Friday…
It’s not a bad gig, especially for those of us who get to escape real winter, and the extended time away from family is certainly easier these days with FaceTime, Facebook and Skype. The best part about it, though, is simply knowing that baseball season is back.
With the exception of a one-week break in March to see my wife and kiddos, I’ll be here for the duration, and then off to the West Coast for Opening Day in Oakland.
As laid out on Indians.com a few days ago, there is certainly no shortage of storylines in Tribe camp this spring, and there are obviously heightened expectations. Terry Francona’s Wild Card-clinching Wahoos won’t be taking anybody by surprise during the 2014 season.
You can keep checking MLB.com and Indians.com for all the latest from Spring Training, and I’ll use this space for a regular round-up of what’s going on with the team, too. Also, if you’re not already, follow me on Twitter (@MLBastian) and Instagram (bastianmlb) for even more updates, quotes, tidbits and photos from Arizona.
Here are some links from the first few days of camp:
- Caught up with Justin Masterson (on his ongoing contract talks) and Vinnie Pestano (on his recent arbitration hearing) on Monday. CLICK HERE to check out the story.
- On Monday night, it was learned that the Indians have an agreement in place on a four-year, $25-million contract with outfielder Michael Brantley. The deal is expected to be officially announced on Thursday.
- In Tuesday’s notebook, All-Star second baseman Jason Kipnis (an extension candidate) discussed how he plans on talking to Brantley and Pestano about their recent negotiation experiences while weighing his own options.
- Also in Tuesday’s notebook, Josh Tomlin talks about his upcoming arbitration hearing (scheduled for Friday), Lonnie Chisenhall addresses his take on the third-base situation, plus a few small tidbits.
- Here’s Tuesday’s story on the official opening of camp. Pitchers and catchers reported, and a handful of players talked about the expectations for this spring and the season ahead.
- On Wednesday, the Indians announced the signing of veteran righty Kyle Davies to a Minor League deal. There is no big-league invite, though. Davies reports to Minors camp next week.
- Wednesday’s notebook includes Francona discussing Brantley’s value to the Tribe, Carlos Carrasco’s chance to earn a spot on the pitching staff and a handful of smaller notes.
- Over on Castroturf, MLB.com’s Anthony Castrovince goes over some decisions by the Indians and how finances have and will come into play.
- Coming to Indians.com later today, a feature on Carlos Santana (pictured above) and his attempt to add third base to the mix this spring.
More on Thursday, when the pitchers and catchers will run through the team’s first official workout.
Cleveland GM Chris Antonetti hasn’t said he’s done tweaking his offense, but it looks pretty set, barring an unexpected trade. I’m going to stick with the hitters for this post, because I’m not as certain that the Tribe’s pitching staff has taken its final shape.
I did this exercise last offseason with varying levels of success when the ’13 season was all said and done. No projection method is without its flaws. Looking at statistical trends can’t predict the shoulder injury that plagued Nick Swisher, or that Michael Bourn’s steady stolen-base numbers would take a nose dive in the American League. It can’t predict the out-of-nowhere seasons of guys like Ryan Raburn or Yan Gomes, neither of whom were in my projections last winter.
All of that said, I’ll stick with a similar approach as last year, averaging the past three years of production against last season’s performance for each player. In a few cases — bench guys or players with thin career samples — I took some liberties to try to get as accurate a projection as possible.
I won’t go deep into the details, suffice to say the numbers I arrived at run similar to many of the projections you might find on fangraphs.com or other sites. At the bottom of this post, I’ll note the projections from last season and compare it to the actual production turned in by Cleveland’s players. Let’s run through each player one by one (I did 12 this time) with a comment on the numbers.
2B Jason Kipnis
Stats: 157 H, 34 2B, 4 3B, 18 HR, 82 RBI, 88 R, 29 SB, 69 BB, 137 K
Comment: Kipnis’ otherworldly June last season gave his overall numbers a decent boost. It’s fair to assume that, without the assistance of that kind of incredible spike over a brief amount of time, the second baseman’s overall showing will suffer a slight dip over 2013. Still, having a middle infielder with an .800-plus OPS to go along with 15-plus homers, 80-plus RBI and around 30 stolen bases is a luxury for the Tribe.
CF Michael Bourn
Stats: 153 H, 24 2B, 8 3B, 6 HR, 51 RBI, 82 R, 33 SB, 47 BB, 137 K
Comment: It’s hard to know what to make of Bourn’s showing in 2013. He didn’t take advantage of his stolen-base chances as much as in the past, but that could change with more experience in the AL. Bourn also dealt with hamstring woes late in the year. Given his production over the past three years combined, it’s fair to assume there will be an uptick in performance by Bourn in ’14. He’ll certainly be motivated to return closer to his career norm.
1B Nick Swisher
Stats: 137 H, 29 2B, 2 3B, 23 HR, 72 RBI, 76 R, 2 SB, 80 BB, 137 K
Comment: Swisher downplayed how much his injured shoulder hurt his offense last season, but there is no denying it was a factor. If he stays out of the outfielder (except for on occasion) and is healed up after the offseason, the switch hitter should see improvement over last year’s numbers. Barring injury, you can usually book Swisher for 20-plus homers, 70-plus RBI and 80-plus walks. Keeping Swisher out of the cleanup spot could help, too.
LF Michael Brantley
Stats: 152 H, 28 2B, 4 3B, 9 HR, 67 RBI, 65 R, 16 SB, 41 BB, 67 K
Comment: The slash line is nearly identical to what Brantley posted for the Indians last season, but the left fielder is also arguably the most consistent hitter on the team. It’s tempting to predict more power, but Brantley is a safe bet to continue on as a gap-to-gap hitter who can steal a few bases and drive in runs while bouncing up and down the lineup. He has one of the top contact rates in the Majors, giving Cleveland a solid protection hitter.
C/1B Carlos Santana
Stats: 140 H, 37 2B, 2 3B, 21 HR, 75 RBI, 76 R, 4 SB, 94 BB, 113 K
Comment: Knowing that Santana might see more time in the field this season actually makes me want to assume the slash line will be even better. He hit much better last year when he wasn’t catching, and Gomes will be taking over as the starter behind the plate. Santana is always a good bet to walk 90-plus times and his breakout showing in 2011 makes 25-30 homers seem possible, if he finally puts the whole package together.
SS Asdrubal Cabrera
Stats: 135 H, 35 2B, 2 3B, 16 HR, 70 RBI, 70 R, 11 SB, 40 BB, 113 K
Comment: I think the Indians would be thrilled if Cabrera returned to this type of production. Last season was discouraging for the shortstop, but he’s not being counted on to carry the lineup and he’s entering a contract year. That could be the kind of situation that helps get the most out of Cabrera, who has the ability to be the team’s best overall hitter. That said, a third straight tank job in the second half is a bad trend. Cleveland needs more from Cabrera in ’14.
C Yan Gomes
Stats: 130 H, 27 2B, 3 3B, 18 HR, 60 RBI, 67 R, 3 SB, 29 BB, 110 K
Comment: Gomes’ brief career and outstanding showing in 2013 inflates this projection, in my opinion. He’ll be dealing with the learning curve that goes along with being a starting catcher in the big leagues for the first time. Yes, he did that in the second half last year, but this is from Opening Day on. There will likely be wear and tear, so I’d expect the average and slugging to drop some more. That said, Gomes has a funny way of proving people wrong.
3B Lonnie Chisenhall
Stats: 106 H, 26 2B, 1 3B, 17 HR, 55 RBI, 49 R, 3 SB, 24 BB, 90 K
Comment: The problem with this projection is that it assumes 450-plus at-bats. If Chisenhall is hitting around .230 with a sub-.280 on-base percentage, I doubt he’s going to get that many at-bats in the big leagues. The Indians might also use him primarily against righties, which has the potential to boost the slash line. I agree that Chisenhall is capable of 15-plus homers, 25-plus doubles and 50-plus RBI over a full season, but he needs to earn that full season.
RF David Murphy
Stats: 106 H, 25 2B, 2 3B, 13 HR, 48 RBI, 53 R, 4 SB, 39 BB, 62 K
Comment: Murphy has the ability to hit for a higher average and on-base percentage than this projection, especially if Cleveland limits him primarily against right-handed pitching. That said, last season’s rough showing really drags the numbers down when trying to predict performance. Being in a new offense and in a platoon role could benefit Murphy, who has hit .300 in the past, but it’s just hard to project that kind of rebound at the moment.
INF Mike Aviles
Stats: 94 H, 18 2B, 1 3B, 10 HR, 47 RBI, 51 R, 10 SB, 16 BB, 48 K
Comment: Aviles garnered 361 at-bats in 2013, which included a stint as the starting shortstop when Cabrera was injured, and this projection is based on around 375 at-bats in ’14. That seems like a fair range (he’s averaged 386 at-bats over the past three years) and the projection looks about right to me. Aviles isn’t going to be an on-base machine, but he’s an adequate hitter capable of spelling starters at multiple positions.
UTIL Ryan Raburn
Stats: 86 H, 24 2B, 1 3B, 16 HR, 59 RBI, 49 R, 1 SB, 31 B, 96 K
Comment: This projection assumes a jump of roughly 100 at-bats for Raburn over his 2013 showing. He enters the year as the right-field platoon partner for Murphy, and could see time at other spots (DH, third base, second base). His incredible showing last season, which earned him an extension, will likely lead to increased playing time. More playing time will likely cause Raburn’s numbers to lag some compared to last year.
DH/PH Jason Giambi
Stats: 32 H, 7 2B, 0 3B, 9 HR, 26 RBI, 19 R, 0 SB, 22 BB, 49 K
Comment: Big G isn’t on the roster at the moment, but he wasn’t on the roster when Spring Training began last season, either. With the versatile Raburn and Aviles still in the fold, and a catching alignment that could mean the Tribe doesn’t have a true backup catcher on the bench, Cleveland appears to have room to carry Giambi again. He’d fill the same pinch hitter/DH role as last year and these numbers look about right to me.
Overall slash line: .260/.328/.423/.751
Overall stats: 1,428 H, 314 2B, 30 3B, 176 HR, 712 RBI, 745 R, 116 SB, 532 BB, 1,159 K
Comment: Obviously, injuries are going to be a part of the season. There’s no avoiding that, so this perfect-world projection of these dozen players amounts to roughly 5,500 at-bats (a tick under average for American League teams in 2013). It doesn’t account for the 300-500 at-bats that unlisted players will probably fill in the coming season. The projection is an improvement on last season’s offense nearly across the board, but with the same amount of runs scored. So, essentially, we’re looking at nearly an identical offense for ’14, a year after it was a Top-five offense in the AL.
Last winter’s projections and actual results
1B Mark Reynolds
Projection: .217/.331/.440, 27 HR, 25 2B, 1 3B, 75 RBI, 71 R, 3 SB, 75 BB, 174 K
Actual: .220/.306/.393, 21 HR, 14 2B, 0 3B, 67 RBI, 55 R, 3 SB, 51 BB, 154 K
2B Jason Kipnis
Projection: .259/.335/.391, 15 HR, 24 2B, 4 3B, 77 RBI, 86 R, 30 SB, 64 BB, 110 K
Actual: .284/.366/.452, 17 HR, 36 2B, 4 3B, 84 RBI, 86 R, 30 SB, 76 BB, 143 K
SS Asdrubal Cabrera
Projection: .272/.336/.421, 17 HR, 33 2B, 2 3B, 69 RBI, 72 R, 11 SB, 49 BB, 102 K
Actual: .242/.299/.402, 14 HR, 35 2B, 2 3B, 64 RBI, 66 R, 9 SB, 35 BB, 114 K
3B Lonnie Chisenhall
Projection: .264/.303/.426, 17 HR, 24 2B, 2 3B, 53 RBI, 57 R, 6 SB, 24 BB, 97 K
Actual: .225/.270/.398, 11 HR, 17 2B, 0 3B, 36 RBI, 30 R, 1 SB, 16 BB, 56 K
C Carlos Santana
Projection: .250/.364/.432, 20 HR, 30 2B, 2 3B, 75 RBI, 74 R, 4 SB, 93 BB, 106 K
Actual: .268/.377/.455, 20 HR, 39 2B, 1 3B, 74 RBI, 75 R, 3 SB, 93 BB, 110 K
OF Michael Brantley
Projection: .280/.337/.390, 6 HR, 34 2B, 5 3B, 58 RBI, 67 R, 14 SB, 50 BB, 67 K
Actual: .284/.332/.396, 10 HR, 26 2B, 3 3B, 73 RBI, 66 R, 17 SB, 40 BB, 67 K
OF Drew Stubbs
Projection: .226/.294/.357, 16 HR, 16 2B, 3 3B, 47 RBI, 80 R, 31 SB, 47 BB, 171 K
Actual: .233/.305/.360, 10 HR, 21 2B, 2 3B, 45 RBI, 59 R, 17 SB, 44 BB, 141 K
OF Nick Swisher
Projection: .273/.365/.476, 24 HR, 34 2B, 1 3B, 90 RBI, 78 R, 2 SB, 76 BB, 136 K
Actual: .246/.341/.423, 22 HR, 27 2B, 2 3B, 63 RBI, 74 R, 1 SB, 77 BB, 138 K
INF Mike Aviles
Projection: .260/.292/.390, 13 HR, 27 2B, 2 3B, 59 RBI, 61 R, 16 SB, 24 BB, 76 K
Actual: .252/.282/.368, 9 HR, 15 2B, 0 3B, 46 RBI, 54 R, 8 SB, 15 BB, 41 K
Overall projection: .251/.325/.404, 280 2B, 28 3B, 169 HR, 679 RBI, 756 R, 141 SB, 575 BB, 1,304 K
Actual production: .255/.327/.410, 290 2B, 23 3B, 171 HR, 711 RBI, 745 R, 117 SB, 562 BB, 1,283 K
Note: At the time of the projections last season, Bourn and Giambi weren’t in the fold and no one knew Raburn or Gomes were going to play such an important role during the season.
I’m going off the grid during the upcoming week, but keep checking Indians.com for updates on the club.
Greetings from the Winter Meetings at the Swan & Dolphin resort. Keep checking back here for a round-up of reports and rumors involving the Indians. Cleveland’s primary need heading into these Meetings was pitching, both for the starting rotation and for the bullpen. Here are the rumblings from around the hotel:
- There are still rumblings about teams inquiring about Justin Masterson (Bob Nightengale of USA Today says the Yankees would love to have him), but it just doesn’t make sense for the Tribe to deal the big sinkerballer right now. Indians GM Chris Antonetti addressed such discussions — while being careful not to specifically talk about negotiations with or about Masterson — on Tuesday. In short: the Indians listen on any players. Click the link for more.
- The Indians have yet to talk about an extension with Masterson, but his camp is not alarmed. The pitcher’s agent, Randy Rowley, is currently preparing case for one-year arbitration talks, but would welcome long-term discussions, too. Such talks can often be included in arbitration negotiations, and often are initiated after Jan. 1. Masterson’s camp is simply interested in a fair deal with respect to the current market for starting pitchers.
- The Indians have a surplus of outfielders (Michael Brantley, Michael Bourn, David Murphy, Drew Stubbs, Ryan Raburn) and are willing to listen on any of them, per Ken Rosenthal of Fox Sports. Stubbs still remains the likely odd-man out given his role and arbitration status.
- Indians are rumored to have interest in veteran infielder Jamey Carroll, according to John Heyman of CBS Sports. He named the Rays and Rangers as other suitors.
- Indians first-base prospect Jesus Aguilar launched two more home runs in the Venezuelan Winter League on Tuesday. He’s now hitting .318/.378/.619 with 16 homers and 45 RBIs in 176 at-bats in the VWL. In 2013, between MLB Spring Training, Double-A and winter ball, all Aguilar has done is post a .287/.357/.476 slash line with 32 home runs, 34 doubles, 152 RBIs, 75 walks, 99 runs and 145 strikeouts in 687 at-bats. Expect him to be at Triple-A this season.
- Rather than a pile of bullet points with updates on Masterson and much more, here’s a one-stop shopping link to a roundup of items from manager Terry Francona and Antonetti. Click here for today’s Winter Meetings notebook.
- Word is the Indians are willing to listen to trade proposals for Masterson. There is no reason to overreact to this right now. Cleveland is doing its due diligence, gauging value for a pitcher in the final year of his contract. Consider that the White Sox are open to listening on Chris Sale and the Rays are doing the same with David Price. The starting pitching market is getting extremely expensive and, if the Indians are considering signing Masterson to an extension, it makes sense to first see what return might be available in a trade.
- The same applies to shortstop Asdrubal Cabrera, though the situation is a little different. Masterson is leading a staff that stands to lose 350-plus innings with Ubaldo Jimenez and Scott Kazmir hitting free agency. Cabrera is coming off a down year, and another subpar second half, and is due to earn $10 million this season. With shortstop Mike Aviles in the fold, and Cleveland needing arms, it makes sense to listen to offers for the shortstop.
- Masterson and Cabrera are a part of Cleveland’s Opening Day plans right now — Masterson, especially — but having such talks now can also lay groundwork for future discussions. In theory, if the Indians endure a terrible first half and 2014 goes off the rails, it would make sense for the Tribe to then resume talks with teams around the Trade Deadline.
- The Indians have interest in free-agent reliever John Axford, who has also been linked to the Cubs, Mariners and Orioles. Axford has closing experience, but might come a little cheaper than free-agents such as Balfour and Fernando Rodney.
- Pitching coach Mickey Callaway, Francona and bullpen coach Kevin Cash met with Indians pitcher Carlos Carrasco at the Meetings on Tuesday. Carrasco (out of options) has first crack at the fifth spot in the rotation, as the roster currently stands. If he doesn’t wind up in the rotation, Carrasco could also transition to the bullpen. Josh Tomlin and Trevor Bauer are also in the fifth-starter mix right now. The rotation landscape would obviously change if the Indians sign a free agent or add an arm via trade.
- Paul Hoynes of the Plain Dealer reported that the Indians are trying to re-sign righty Tyler Cloyd to a Minor League deal after designating him for assignment to clear room for OF David Murphy. Hoynes also reported that the Indians were impressed by Cuban shortstop prospect Erisbel Arrubarrena in a workout, but noted that the Dodgers, Cubs and Yankees are also involved.
- Former Indians prospect Drew Pomeranz, and Minor League righty Chris Jensen, were traded to the A’s in exchange for lefty Brett Anderson.
- Tribe fans hoping to land Mark Trumbo will also be disappointed to learn he was dealt to the D-backs in a three-team trade involving the White Sox and Angels. L.A reeled in pitchers Hector Santiago and Tyler Skaggs, Arizona netted Trumbo (plus two PTBNL’s) and the ChiSox landed outfielder Adam Eaton.
- Was able to confirm a report by Rosenthal that the Indians have expressed interest in reliever Joba Chamberlain. Rosenthal named the Tigers, D-backs, Rockies and Cubs as other clubs showing varying levels of interest in the pitcher.
- We already knew Carlos Santana was going to try his hand soon at third base, but on Day 1 of the Meetings, Antonetti noted that the team is still evaluating how much time the catcher will spend behind the plate. Cleveland is definitely in the market for a third-string catcher with big league experience, but the club might also consider backup options if it is determined it is best served with Santana in a 1B/DH/3B-exclusive role.
- The Indians made two announcements on Monday: they signed first baseman David Cooper to a Major League contract and infielder Jose Ramirez might need surgery after injuring his left thumb in winter ball. Cooper will continue an incredible comeback story with a shot at earning a bench job for the Indians this spring.
- The Indians recently lost out on signing reliever Edward Mujica (two-year deal with Red Sox) in their search for bullpen help. On the first day of the Meetings, Cleveland was reported to have interest in Grant Balfour. If an available arm has late-inning experience, the Tribe is looking into it.
- Cleveland expressed interest in free-agent right-hander Jason Hammel (to the point that Callaway spoke with the pitcher). Hammel is reportedly seeking a three- or four-year deal, though, which likely takes the Indians out of the running.
- Former Indians closer Chris Perez — a free agent — was on hand at the Swan and Dolphin on Monday to meet with interested teams. Former Indians outfielder Grady Sizemore is also expected to be at the Meetings this week to do the same thing.
- Indians outfield prospect Tyler Naquin (selected by the Indians with the 15th pick in the 2012 Draft) was named to the Arizona Fall League’s 2013 Top Prospects Team. In 27 games, Naquin posted a .339/.400/.417 slash line with six extra-base hits, 18 RBIs and 22 runs scored.
Stay tuned for more…
Between official MLB meetings, general managers and agents gather to discuss free agents and trades, and plenty tends to get done given the face-to-face aspect of the event. For the Indians, the goal now is fairly specific.
“Pitching,” Indians GM Chris Antonetti said. “We’re still focused on trying to improve our pitching alternatives. We come into the offseason in a much better position than we have in prior offseasons with the quality and quantity of our alternatives that we currently have on our roster and within the organization. That said, we’re going to continue to try to find a way to improve it.”
That goes without saying, considering Cleveland stands to lose the 559 1/3 innings logged last year by Ubaldo Jimenez, Scott Kazmir, Joe Smith, Matt Albers, Rich Hill and Chris Perez. Kazmir (A’s) and Smith (Angels) have already headed West, and the rest could be gone via free agency as well. That’s a considerable chunk of innings to replace, whether that’s via internal or external options.
Antonetti discussed the coming Meetings and a wide array of topics during a lunch sit-down with Indians reporters on Friday afternoon. There was no hard news, but there were plenty of notes about the team and its approach as the Winter Meetings draw closer.
Here are some highlights from Antonetti’s Q&A session…
On landscape of American League Central:
“Every team is going out to try to improve themselves heading into the following year. So far this offseason, it’s been no exception. The Tigers and the Twins and the Royals have all made moves to improve themselves. The White Sox added a really good player in [Jose] Abreu, too. I expect it to be a very competitive division. Hopefully we’ll be right there in the mix.”
On perception that Indians have been relatively inactive:
“We went into the offseason with a defined set of needs, and in a much better position than maybe the last few offseasons. Really, some of our strategy last offseason was to put ourselves in a stronger position this offseason, where we acquired players that would fit and impact our roster beyond just the 2013 season. So now that we’re looking at 2014, some of those same players we acquired last year, we expect will impact us going forward. That’s lessened some of the needs going into this offseason.”
On approaching last offseason with this offseason’s market in mind:
“We try to do the best that we can to look forward. There were a lot of factors that pointed to this being a … [pause] … free agency is an expensive process and a challenging process to work through for a lot of reasons. This offseason, there were even more factors probably contributing to that.”
On losing Jimenez and Kazmir to free agency:
“Well, only one has happened so far, with the loss of Kaz. But both guys made very meaningful contributions to our team last year and were a big part of our success. It’s going to sound redundant, but we feel like we have quality in-house alternatives. If you look at where our rotation is now compared to where our rotation was last year, we’re in a much better spot.”
On viewing it as losing one set of innings, not two, due to emergence of Danny Salazar:
“Right. And hopefully we get more innings from Corey [Kluber] and more innings from Zach [McAllister]. Josh Tomlin is going to be unrestricted coming into this year. Carlos Carrasco will come into the year unrestricted. We feel like we’ve got a number of alternatives and a number of quality alternatives.”
On having success with reclamation projects such as Kazmir:
“We’ll spend time trying to find those guys again this offseason. Really, our medical staff and our coaches do a really good job of working together. Our medical staff, our strength and conditioning staff and our on-field staff have a coordinated approach to try to put those guys in the best position to be successful.”
On adding from outside organization to improve rotation and bullpen:
“I’m not sure we need to. Our preference would be, if we find the right guys at the right value, to try to improve our alternatives.”
On possibly acquiring more position players:
“I think we addressed what we felt was one of our primary offseason objectives, improving against right-handed pitching, by signing David Murphy. Now, we’ll continue to look at options to try to find ways to improve, but our focus right now is on pitching.”
On trades possibly being more feasible given free-agent asking prices:
“The trade prices haven’t been inexpensive, either. We’re engaged in both. We’re engaged with both free agents and trades. Which one is more likely, it’s hard to say. We actually have outstanding offers both ways, on trades and free agents. So we could go either direction, or both.”
On current bullpen:
“It’s a youthful group, but we have guys that we feel are capable of pitching and capable of absorbing some of those innings. Some of those guys are guys we’re hopeful will have bounceback years, guys like Vinnie Pestano. And other guys from our Minor League system who we expect to contribute and take up some of those innings. But again, if we can find some guys externally to fortify that group, that’s certainly something we’ll look to do.”
On solving closer role internally:
“We could. With Bryan [Shaw] and Cody [Allen], we feel both of those guys have not only the stuff, but the makeup to pitch in the most highly leveraged innings. They did that last year and excelled in those roles, but they weren’t the ones primarily responsible for getting the 27th out. But we feel that they are both well-equipped to do that. But they don’t have the experience.”
On potentially signing a free-agent to be the new closer:
“There are a number of alternatives out there externally that have experience at the end of games. Now, whether or not we’ll align on those values, it’s still too early in the offseason to say. But there are a number of guys out there with that experience.”
On Pestano’s progress this offseason:
“He’s doing well. His mindset is in a good spot. He’s anticipating going to the complex and working hard to put himself in a better position coming into this season. He is set on having a much better year this year than he did last year.”
On what the organization learned about Trevor Bauer last season:
“That he cares a great deal about being really good, and he’s willing to work really hard to do it. … We’ve always had good dialogue with Trevor from the day we acquired him, and that’s continued through today. I think it’s one thing to know what you want to do, and it’s another thing to be able to accomplish it. Pitching at a high level is really hard to do. I think Trevor got to t level pitching one way, and was very successful doing it, but he undertook considerable delivery adjustments that he initiated last offseason, and I think maybe we and he, if anything, underestimated the magnitude of those adjustments and maybe how long it would take him to get to the point where he’s comfortable executing that delivery consistently. … The videos that we’ve seen, he’s continued to work toward our joint vision of what we think his delivery should be.”
On Michael Bourn’s recovery from hamstring surgery:
“He’s doing well. His recovery is on track and he’ll come into Spring Training without restrictions. He’ll have a relatively normal offseason, too, in terms of conditioning.”
On Carlos Santana playing some third base in winter ball:
“We’ll see. We were really encouraged by the approach Carlos took. He really is passionate about wanting to find a way to impact the team any way he can. He said, ‘Hey, I’ll do what I can to try to find a way to find a way to play another position.’ He recognized how well Yan [Gomes] caught, and how important Yan was and the contributions he made to our team. So Carlos took it upon himself and said, ‘Hey, I’ll not only catch, but if I can be serviceable at third base, that gives Tito [manager Terry Francona] potentially another option. So, to his credit, he’s down there, he’s worked at it, he’s been at the complex, he’s taking ground balls there and now he’ll progress into games at winter ball for a to-be-determined amount of time, but for at least a month.”
On Asdrubal Cabrera’s showing last season:
“It was probably less consistent than Asdrubal’s performance have been in the past, but the one thing about Asdrubal is he never wavered in how he approached the game, the teammate he was. Throughout the course of the season, he worked hard to find a way to contribute. Last offseason, he worked hard, came into Spring training in good shape. He just may not have had the numbers he had in other years, but it wasn’t for a lack of effort.”
On Carrasco’s role within the pitching staff:
“He’ll be on the team. He’s going to be on the team either way — he’s out of options. We think he’s got a chance to still be a very good Major League starting pitcher. So he’s going to condition this offseason as a starter. That obviously gives he and us the flexibility to adjust from there. If we determine as a team that we’re better served having him in the bullpen, we can make that adjustment in Spring Training. But he’s been a very successful starter in the Minor Leagues and, prior to his injury, at the Major League level was a successful starter. We think that he’s certainly capable of doing that again.”
On importance of this spring for third baseman Lonnie Chisenhall:
“Every winter is important for every player and every spring is important, especially for any young player With Lonnie, it coms down to just he has a ton of ability. That’s clear. That’s been evident. He needs to work to figure out a way to become a consistent Major League player. I have no doubt that, if Lonnie puts in the work — offensively, defensively, conditioning — that he’ll be a really good Major League player.”
On continuing to give Chisenhall chances in light of struggles:
“I think it’s about us trying to build the best team and best organization, and figuring out how Lonnie fits into that. We’ll have a better sense of that once we get through the offseason, about what our options are. But Lonnie can’t control any of that. The only thing that Lonnie can control is what he does this winter, how he prepares for Spring Training and take advantage of the opportunity that’s there in front of him. Without question, regardless of what the role is for Lonnie to start the year, we’ll be a much better team if he’s contributing to our Major League team next year the way we think he’s capable of doing.”
On possibly continuing to limit Chisenhall’s at-bats against left-handed pitching:
“That’s a possibility. I think a lot of it will depend upon what our roster construction is, and also how things go this spring for Lonnie. It’s always a balance. Our goal is to win as many games as we can next year, to get back to the playoffs and to advance further than we did this past year. That’s what we’d like to do. That will be our primary motivation. With that, we’ll try to balance the individual development of the younger guys on the roster, including Lonnie.”
On Salazar’s ceiling as a starting pitcher:
“I wouldn’t want to set any ceiling on Danny. Danny deserves a lot of credit for the way he worked through his [elbow] rehab. He made considerable adjustments to his delivery as he was progressing through the rehab process to put him in a better position to be durable long term. I think we’ve seen the benefits of that. He’s a really athletic guy that works hard and has a lot of ingredients to be a really successful Major League pitcher. Where that settles for him, I wouldn’t want to limit it.”
On going 4-15 against the Tigers last season:
“We don’t really look at any one way about a particular opponent. Inevitably, there are going to be teams in a given year that you fare better against others. I think I joked about this before, is anyone asking the Tigers why they couldn’t beat anyone but the Indians? Because our record against everyone else was better than the Tigers. Again, when you look at the balance of a 162 game schedule, a lot of different things can happen. I would expect us to better against the Tigers next year, but maybe not go 17-2 against the White Sox. I don’t think when you play a team 19 games against a team, you can expect it to be that lopsided either way.”
On his reaction to the Tigers trading Prince Fielder and Doug Fister:
“That I expect them to be a better team next year. Dave Dombrowski is extraordinarily good at what he does, at building a roster and an organization. I’m quite confident that they will once again build a very strong team for next year. And they got a lot of good players back.”
On not having to face Miguel Cabrera and Fielder back to back in Detroit’s lineup:
“Well, yeah, but there are other guys you need to face. Individually, am I happy that we don’t have to face Prince Fielder? Yeah. But now we have to face Ian Kinsler instead, and there are other guys that will fill that lineup. I know and am very confident that Detroit is going to have a very good and very formidable lineup. They already do.”
On Justin Masterson’s showing last season:
“It was a really good year. Justin, I think, if you reflect back on the year that he had this year, he was one of the better pitchers in the American League for a large portion of the season. He ended up transitioning to the bullpen at the end of the year, because we had an opportunity there and it as really a selfless thing for Justin to do, to try to figure out a way where he can help impact the team while he was not yet built back up to full strength. I think Justin deserves a lot of credit for that.”
On younger players vying for bullpen jobs:
“They’re all viable. As it stands now, we’ll have considerable competition in our bullpen going into Spring Training with only a handful of guys probably locked into roles, maybe less than a handful actually.”
On any virtual locks for the rotation behind Masterson:
“[Kluber and McAllister] are in a good spot heading into Spring Training. And then [Salazar], if he continues to work and comes into Spring Training in a similar place as he has in the past, then he’s in a good spot, too. But again, maybe not a certainty. And then we have other guys in that group with Josh Tomlin, Carlos Carrasco, Trevor Bauer.”
On prospect Francisco Lindor’s recovery from his back injury:
“He’s fine. He has a relatively normal offseason. He’s down working on his strength and conditioning. He’s got a pretty good offseason routine. His back is fine.”
Right field will have a new look for the Indians in 2014. Cleveland has agreed to a two-year, $12-million contract with outfielder David Murphy, and the deal includes a club option for 2016. Things will be made official once Murphy completes a physical.
You can expect Murphy — a veteran of eight Major League seasons between stints with the Red Sox and Rangers — to play a lot of right field. What that means for Ryan Raburn or Drew Stubbs remains to be seen. As of right now, a lefty-righty platoon of either Murphy-Raburn or Murphy-Stubbs makes the most sense.
What might the production of those platoons look like? We’ll get to that in a moment. First…
Could the Indians carry Michael Brantley (left field), Michael Bourn (center), Murphy, Raburn and Stubbs on the roster? The flexibility of players such as Raburn (corner outfield, second and third base, DH), Nick Swisher (first base, right field, DH), Carlos Santana (catcher, first base, DH) and Mike Aviles (corner outfield, all over the infield) make it possible.
Cleveland could also clear up this perceived outfield logjam by attempting to trade Stubbs, who is arbitration eligible this winter. The Indians might also consider non-tendering Stubbs prior to the Dec. 2 deadline for offering a contract to arbitration players. That would provide some salary relief for the pursuit of other roster needs.
For now, the outfield in Cleveland is crowded, and that leaves everything else up to speculation.
The heart of this signing is Murphy’s consistent track record, experience in all three outfield spots and his numbers against right-handed pitching. Yes, the 32-year-old Murphy had a down year in 2012 (.220/282/.374), but he also seemed to fall victim to some hard luck (.227 BaBIP compared to .302 for his career). Consider that Murphy actually saw improvement in his strikeout-to-walk ratio, had nearly an identical groundball-flyball ratio (.79) as his career rate (.80) and posted a line-drive percentage (22) near his career rate (20). Murphy’s contact rate (85 percent) was also in line with his career performance (84 percent).
Taking all of that information into account, along with Murphy’s slash line of .283/.346/.449 over the 2008-12 seasons, and it’s easy to see why he’d be a strong bounceback candidate for 2014.
It might not be fair to judge Murphy only on his subpar production in 2013, just as it’s not entirely fair to look at Raburn’s 2013 (.901 OPS) or 2012 (.480 OPS) in a vacuum. As for Stubbs, well, his 2013 slash line (.233/.305/.360) was pretty close to his career rate (.239/.310/.381). At this point, Stubbs is what he is: a better center fielder than right fielder, and a player with plus speed and a solid ability to hit lefties.
True, Stubbs was less exposed as a No. 9 hitter for Cleveland than he was as a leadoff man for the Reds in previous seasons, but putting the outfielder in an everyday role cost the Tribe some offense against right-handed pitching. Over the course of his career, Stubbs has hit .274 (.796 OPS) against lefties, compared to .226 (.652) against righties. In 2013, his showing vs. right-handers dipped to .216 (.637).
On the season, the Indians saw right-handers 67.5 percent of the time (4,163 plate appearances out of 6,665). Among Cleveland’s right fielders in 2013, Stubbs drew 50.5 percent of the plate appearances (318-of-630). The Indians went into the season hoping Stubbs’ speed and defense could help make up for the expected performance against righties as an everyday right fielder. That wasn’t the case, and that’s why a free-agent signing like Murphy comes into play as a possible way to upgrade.
So, again, what might a Murphy-Raburn or Murphy-Stubbs platoon look like? Hang with me now…
Over the past five seasons, the Indians had a 69.8/30.2 percentage split when it came to plate appearances against righties and lefties. With that in mind, I projected based upon a 70/30 line. Cleveland’s right fielders (Stubbs, Raburn, Swisher, Matt Carson, Jason Kubel and Ezequiel Carrera) accounted for 630 plate appearances in 2013, though the average for all nine positions was 675 PAs. Right field was lower due to the position being lower in the lineup most of the time.
The three main right fielders (Stubbs, Raburn and Swisher) accounted for 610 plate appearances. With that in mind, I projected based on 600 PAs for a Murphy-Raburn or Murphy-Stubbs platoon. That leaves anywhere between 25-75 plate appearances for other players, which we’re tossing out for the sake of this experiment. Using the 70/30 split, that creates a PA split of 420/180 for the platoon. To project the numbers, I used the combined 2011-13 production of Murphy (vs. RHP), Raburn and Stubbs (each vs. LHP). A three-year sample tends to be more accurate than looking at one isolated season.
Cleveland Right Field total production 2013:
Stats: 139 H, 30 2B, 1 3B, 24 HR, 79 RBI, 59 BB, 243 TB
Stubbs, Raburn and Swisher in RF in 2013:
Stats: 132 H, 29 2B, 1 3B, 23 HR, 75 RBI, 56 BB, 232 TB
Murphy-Raburn platoon projection for 2014:
Stats: 144 H, 36 2B, 2 3B, 21 HR, 66 RBI, 53 BB, 247 TB
Murphy-Stubbs platoon projection for 2014:
Stats: 147 H, 28 2B, 3 3B, 19 HR, 67 RBI, 58 BB, 238 TB
The goal is to upgrade the production from right field and, whether going with Raburn or Stubbs as a pairing with Murphy, the signing projects to accomplish precisely that. Granted, there are flaws in the projection, because it goes without saying that Murphy would also face lefties in spots and Raburn or Stubbs would also see at-bats against righties. The projection is that of a platoon in the purest sense, and it’s just to give you an idea of what the expected performance could look like in 2014.
This might not be a “wow” move that excites the fan base, but it’s a reasonably-priced move that should result in an improved offensive showing out of right field. If you like intangibles, Murphy also has veteran leadership skills, playoff experience and a history with manager Terry Francona. Things like that can’t be quantified, but they are also important for a team that is trying to take the next step after winning 92 games and tasting the postseason.
Now, about that rotation…
FIVE ADDED TO TRIBE’S 40-MAN ROSTER
Wednesday marked the deadline to add Rule 5-eligible players to the 40-man roster in order to protect them from exposure to the annual selection process. Cleveland purchased the contracts of RHP Bryan Price (Triple-A Columbus), RHP Austin Adams (Double-A Akron), 1B Jesus Aguilar (Double-A), OF Carlos Moncrief (Double-A) and INF Erik Gonzalez (Class A Carolina). In order to add all five to the roster, infielder Cord Phelps was designated for assignment.
Tribe GM Chris Antonetti discussed each player with reporters after the 3 p.m. ET announcement.
Antonetti, on Price: “In Bryan’s case, it was a guy that really thrived this year at Triple-A. He made a lot of progress in how he attacked hitters. He features a good fastball and two good secondary pitches. He was one of the more effective relievers in all of Triple-A.”
Antonetti, asked if Price could compete for MLB bullpen job this spring: “He could, yes. He’ll come into camp and we’ll have to see how things shake out in our bullpen, but he could b a guy who comes in and earns a spot.”
Price (Double-A/Triple-A) in 2013:
47 games, 2.04 ERA, 75 IP, 92 K, 16 BB, .206 average
Antonetti, on Adams: “Austin bounced back from his shoulder surgery extraordinarily well. He worked really hard to get back to where he was pre-surgery. He’s got one of the best arms, not only in our system, but throughout the Minor Leagues. He has a good complement of secondary pitches as well, and misses a lot of bats. He’s another guy who we feel isn’t too far from contributing at the Major League level, if he continues to make progress.”
Adams (Double-A) in 2013:
45 games, 2.62 ERA, 55 IP, 76 K, 29 BB, .215 average
Antonetti, on Aguilar: “He’s getting closer. He made a lot of progress from last year to this year. The Double-A level is always a good test, especially for position players, and Jesus did a really good job of anchoring that lineup. He’s continuing his work down there in winter ball and is off to an extraordinary start down there. He’s continued to work hard. He has a really bright future and he’s on a good path developmentally.”
Antonetti, asked about Aguilar playing some third base in winter ball: “They had a lot of injuries on their winter ball team, so Jesus has gone over there and played some third base. It’s always good to increase your versatility.”
Antonetti, asked if Indians might consider more time at third for Aguilar: “We’d have to see how that continues to go. It wasn’t something that was top-of-mind for us as the season ended. But the fact that he’s gotten an opportunity and experience down in winter ball, it’s something we’ll look to see and maybe continue as we head to Spring Training. But right now, we still view him primarily as a first baseman.”
Aguilar (Double-A) in 2013:
.275/.349/.427, 16 HR, 28 2B, 105 RBI, 66 R, 130 games
Antonetti, on Moncrief: “He was one of the highlights of our development system this year. He’s a guy that’s made a lot of progress, really, if you look at what he’s done, and how he continued his development as a hitter. He really cut down on his strikeout rate, and really continued to improve his defense in the outfield to the point where he’s now a very good outfielder with a well above-average arm with good reads and routes. That’s now become a strength for him and he’s continued to improve as a hitter. Given his limited experience as a hitter, because he started his professional career as a pitcher, it’s been encouraging to see the progress he’s made.”
Moncrief (Double-A) in 2013:
.284/.354/.470, 17 HR, 26 2B, 7 3B, 75 RBIs, 77 R, 129 games
Antonetti, on Gonzalez: “He’s another great development story. Erik’s one of the hardest workers and best teammates in our organization. He did a tremendous job of improving himself as a player. He’s a guy that’s always been a really good defensive player, and he’s worked hard at every position he’s played on the field. We gave him the opportunity to play some shortstop and he really excelled there. We think he’s got a chance to be an above-average defender no matter where he plays defensively, whether that’s shortstop, second base, he can play the corners on the infield, he can play the outfield, and he continues to improve as a hitter. As much as any player in our system, he’s made progress through his hard work this year.”
Gonzalez (Class A Lake County/Carolina) in 2013:
.254/.293/.417, 9 HR, 32 2B, 12 3B, 76 RBI, 75 R, 132 games
Who is eligible for the Rule 5 Draft?
Players first signed at age 18 must be added to 40-man rosters within five seasons or they become eligible to be drafted by other organizations through the Rule 5 process. Players signed at 19 years or older have to be protected within four seasons. Clubs pay $50,000 to select a player in the Major League phase of the Rule 5 Draft, slated to take place on Thursday, Dec. 12. If that player doesn’t stay on the 25-man roster for the full season, he must be offered back to his former team for $25,000.
In other words, an international player or high school draftee signed in 2009, assuming they were 18 or under as of June 5 of that year, must be protected. A college player taken in the 2010 Draft is in the same boat.
Among the Rule 5 eligible players for the Indians are right-handers Joseph Colon, Tyler Holt, Bryce Stowell, Enosil Tejeda and Giovanny Urshela; lefties Elvis Araujo, Matt Packer and Giovanni Soto; first baseman Chun Chen; outfielder LeVon Washington; and catcher Alex Monsalve.