Revisionist Swishtory

SwisherDo you remember how excited Nick Swisher was at his introductory press conference with the Indians? Do you, loyal Tribe fan, remember how excited you were at the time, too? It was a Merry Swish-mas! The switch-hitting, living, breathing can of Red Bull had signed with Cleveland and we all suddenly lived in Bro-hio.

Do you recall his first day in Indians camp during Spring Training? He unpacked his stuff, singing his own made-up tune (“It’s Triiibe Time!”) while teammates chuckled and figured Swisher’s energy and enthusiasm would help cure any lingering effects of the 94-loss season in 2012. He roared through the clubhouse on Tito’s scooter, jabbed reporters in the shoulder after questions, handed out high fives daily. Swisher immediately changed the culture.

On Day 1, here was what one of his teammates said: “That’s definitely somebody you want to have on your team. For him to be the kind of leader, and vocal leader, that he is, that’s definitely going to be something we need.”

With Swisher, and Michael Bourn, now in Atlanta, try to remember.

Underneath the bitter pile of frustration and anger over diminished performance, unexpected injuries, roster limitations and a tightened payroll, try to remember the good vibes that existed when both Swisher and Bourn signed with the Indians. You’d be hard-pressed to find anyone — in the media or among fans — who knocked the deals at the time. Both were top-flight free-agents, and they came to Cleveland?

These were veterans with track records and there was little to nothing that said they couldn’t be productive for the Tribe over the life of their respective four-year deals.

“The free agent stuff, sometimes it’s a little bit of a crapshoot,” Indians manager Terry Francona said earlier this week. “That was one of the things I think we had really hung our hat on, was the level of consistency both guys had had.”

MLB Trade Rumors — as reliable a resource as any for projections, speculation and rumor roundups — ranked Bourn as the third-best free-agent before the 2013 season. Swisher was ranked sixth that winter. The site noted that Bourn might be in line for “Torii Hunter money,” referring to the five-year, $90-million pact inked by Hunter in 2007. As for Swisher, no one expected a $100-million contract, but he was viewed as “a fine addition to any lineup.”

Prior to 2013, Swisher hit .256/.361/.468 with an average of 26 homers, 31 doubles, 83 walks and 83 RBIs in 149 games each season. He had just one stint on the disabled list — in 2005 for a shoulder issue. In that eight-year time period, he averaged 4.20 pitches per plate appearance (ninth-best in the Majors in that span). Only five players had seen more pitches than Swisher. Consistency, health and a good eye often mean a player will age fairly well.

Swisher got four years and $56 million. The largest free-agent deal in team history.

BournBefore 2013, Bourn hit .280/.348/.378 with an average of four homers, 28 doubles, 10 triples, 45 RBIs, 61 walks, 93 runs and 54 stolen bases in 153 games in that four-year span. He stole 257 bases from 2008-12 (51 per year and the most in the Majors overall). From ’09-12, he ranked first in MLB in steals, fourth in triples, 10th in runs and 13th in hits. Even if Bourn, 30 years old at the time, wasn’t going to keep swiping 50 bases (or even 40) per year, expecting 30 per season wasn’t unrealistic.

Bourn got four years and $48 million. No pun intended, it was a steal. (OK, pun intended.)

“That was a big part of why he acquired him, was defense in center field and disrupting the game,” Francona said. “He just wasn’t able to disrupt the game like we’d hoped, as often as we’d hoped.”

The Indians couldn’t see the future. They couldn’t possibly predict that Swisher — mostly healthy for his entire career — would break down, hurt both knees and see the leg issues cost him two-years worth of expected production. The Indians couldn’t predict that Bourn would rupture a hamstring in the Wild Card-clinching game in 2013, creating an issue that lingered through 2014. They couldn’t know that, even when healthy in ’15, Bourn wouldn’t be the same player. They figured he might steal 46 bases in a season — not total over the 331 games he’d be in an Indians’ uniform.

In the clubhouse, Bourn had the bigger impact over the past three seasons. After tough defeats, as a veteran on a relatively young team, Bourn was often one of the only position players around when reporters walked into the room. He’d make himself available, taking the heat off some teammates. That kind of accountability goes a long way. And, from his comments, you could tell his diminished production ate at him. You can complain all you want about Bourn’s numbers, and have every right, but he cared and put in the work.

During the 2013 season, Swisher had a good impact on the clubhouse, too. His performance down the stretch played a key role in reaching the playoffs and his energy was unquestionably welcomed after the Tribe’s turbulent 2012 season. Once the injuries struck, and the performance dropped, though, Swisher’s all-out personality didn’t always work well behind the scenes. Some people within the organization don’t mind seeing him in a new uniform.

And, really, that’s kind of a shame. Given the way Swisher embraced the Indians organization and the fan base, and with the charity work he and his wife did both here and elsewhere, this could have been a perfect marriage under different circumstances. As I posted on Twitter after the trade went down, Swisher could’ve owned this town, rather than being run out of it.

“When we signed both guys,” Indians general manager Chris Antonetti said, “we were hopeful that they would help expedite our return to competitiveness. And in the 2013 season, both guys were key contributors to us making the postseason. Unfortunately, since that time, things haven’t played out maybe the way anyone would’ve hoped, and so that got us to [this point].

“At this point, we had to not necessarily dwell on the past, but figure out the path forward. We felt this move made sense for us and allows us that flexibility that would be helpful for us as we build our teams.”

This team needed a culture change heading into 2013, and it needs one again heading into 2016.

Trading Swisher and Bourn was needed in order to begin that process.

But, try to remember what it was like when they signed.

Remember how many times Swisher used the word “excited” when he first donned a Cleveland uniform? True to his persona, Swisher still used that word as he emptied his locker on Friday.

“I’m just excited, packing up all my stuff,” Swisher said. “I’m really just excited to get back on the field and play again — just be myself. Everything that’s went down here in the last year-and-a-half has been tough. Not only for myself, but organizationally as well. I just wish these guys the best of luck in everything they do and I hope they do the same for me.”

–JB

13 Comments

Excellent article by Mr. Bastian. We were all excited about these signings. However. doesn’t one just have to question the Indians scouting department. A thorough report should have alerted some red flags. Moreover ,why do we have so few young pitching prospects at Columbus, etc. The Yankees have a plethora of great promising arms and we have Will Roberts and who else? Just wondering!

These guys were way over-ranked, and overpaid when they signed.

Swisher was batting 8th in the Yankees line up with an average around .250. He had better hitters surrounding him there. He never was a clean up hitter. Bourns last year in Atlanta his average dropped and he never played 162 games. The closet he came was three times in his career of around 155 games. The problem is the front office was too quick to spend money.

“Both were top-flight free-agents, and they came to Cleveland?” I wish you guys wouldn’t do this. You’re just perpetuating the negative misconception about Cleveland. STOP IT.

You are right alansafe, both were regarded as good free agent signings at the time. No mortal person can predict the future, all we can go on is their ‘track record’ up until that point in their career. We now need a right handed power bat to drive in the runners on base and this management shouldn’t be gun shy to acquire one now that Swish and Bourn are out of the way.

Please, Cleveland is not a real city and the weather is not good

Who are all these great Yankee pitching prospects your talking about clay dunlap? Besides from Severino they don’t have any other highly ranked pitching prospects.

The Cleveland line wasn’t about the city itself. I love this city and am proud to call it home. You can swap out “Cleveland” for “the Indians” and it still applies. What it was in reference to was the well-established history of top free agents not signing here, whether by their choice or due to the team’s hesitance to spend on the open market. When Swisher and Bourn signed here, it was surprising, given the history of Cleveland and free agency.

After re-examine a lot of the free agent signings, I see a trend of the older veterans not living up to their past performances, It’s like they get their money and retire!
Then on their last year of their contract, they regain their past performance level, hmmm sounds sort of fishy don’t you think?
The Indians did a good thing in trading Swish & Bourn. I wish them good luck! I like our youth a lot better and maybe we all learned a little from those signings.

Pingback: Discover: Tuesday Takeaways « MLB.com Blogs

Why should Tribe fans put their faith in the same people who keep making the same mistakes over and over again? 15 years and only 3 playoffs. 15 years of bad drafts. Plus, they love shopping bargain basement free agents. You get what you pay for.
But yet we will hear the excuse from the front office. “Small market city. Only compete every 5 years. Fans fault for not coming out to see team play.” Never the front offices fault.

bingo – i love being talked down to by indians team president and general manager as if i don;t understand the “market realities” which the indians have to compete against. youve been at this job for 15 years idiots – you are paid to figure out how to circumvent this issues. you took the job with full knowledge of what you were getting yourself into.

i hate you mark shapiro – you make me turn on my favorite team. can no longer support a team that has mark shapiro in charge as well as a shapiro puppet in the form of chris antonetti.

We the fans should never accept this 5 year plan the front office preaches. What it does for them is give them longer time to make up more excuses and not win. If you are an owner you are suppose to win the world series not just be in play offs. If you have a front office that does everything right you should be able to compete every year. Some years better than others. What has this regime done to draw fans to the ball park. I know fireworks dollar hot dog days, all of these side things are to deceive the real issues. None of these things produce winning. Having good players produce wins. How many of you would give up fireworks, dollar dog days for a championship?
This front office has no reason to be in a hurry to produce a winning team. They have drafted poorly and have thumb their noses at the fans. Success breeds winning. Winning brings fans to the park consistently. Winning brings money. Blaming the fans for not coming to see a third place team is ridiculous. Dolans are lazy they refuse to replace the people who keep making the mistakes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: