Examining the Tribe bullpen with BER

UeharaIt doesn’t take too much number crunching to realize how good Red Sox reliever Koji Uehara has been this season. Just scan his pitching line. It’s all right there in front of you. What this postseason has done, though, is help the country realize just how historically great the righty has been this year.

Examining Uehara’s numbers got me thinking again about a stat I’ve been contemplating for a couple seasons. I’m calling it Bullpen Efficiency Rate. Basically, a reliever’s job is to get in and get out as quickly and efficiently as possible. I wanted a number that summed that up and wasn’t hard to calculate.

Here’s what I eventually settled on: (Outs + ROE) / (Batters Faced – IBB)

The goal here is to determine the percentage of time a reliever is efficient in creating the desired result. I added Reached On Error to Outs, because — generally speaking — a pitcher did his job in an ROE situation, whether that’s inducing a ground ball or creating a fly ball that is then misplayed by the fielder. For the second part, I subtracted Intentional Walks from Batters Faced, because that stat is extremely situational, and often called by the manager and out of the pitcher’s control.

After poring through both good and bad seasons by a wide range of relievers, here is the scale I came up with for the results:

86-90% = Unhuman
81-85% = Elite
76-80% = Great
71-75% = Good
66-70% = Poor
61-65% = Send Help

Here are the 2013 numbers for the Indians’ most-used relievers:

1. Joe Smith 74.7
2. Bryan Shaw 73.9
3. Marc Rzepczynski 73.8 (STL/CLE)
4. Matt Albers 73.6
5. Cody Allen 71.9
6. Nick Hagadone 71.2
7. Chris Perez 68.0
8. Vinnie Pestano 67.1
9. Rich Hill 65.9

That is why, in an earlier post, I went with Smith over Allen as my pick for the Tribe’s best reliever for 2013, even though their other numbers were very similar across the board. Shaw is a great example of how including ROE and IBB can alter the stat. Without ROE and IBB, his BER would be 71.2 percent. Shaw was a little snakebit, though, with seven ROE this past season. Take that and IBB into account and his BER spikes by 2.7 percent.

For comparison, Uehara posted a BER of 85.2 in 2013, giving him one of the greatest relief seasons in baseball history. The closest I could find — in a search of single relief seasons from 1950-2013 (min. 50 innings) , sorted by highest FIP — was Dennis Eckersley, who posted an 85.1 BER in his incredible 1990 season. The best FIP since 1950 belongs to Craig Kimbrel in 2012, when he had an 82.3 BER. Behind Kimbrel on that list are Eric Gagne (2003; 81.6 BER), Eckersley (1990) and Greg Holland (2013; 80.3 BER).

Mariano Rivera had an 83.0 BER in 2008, which was arguably the best season of his Hall-of-Fame-caliber career. And the long-time Yankees closer had a 77.1 BER during his time in the big leagues.

On the other side of the equation, John Pacella posted the worst FIP in the sample I pulled from 1950-2013, back in 1982. His BER that year was 63.3. Another rough season was Mike DeJean in 1999, when he had a 66.4 BER. For Indians fans who want to forget all about the Brett Myers Experiment, his BER in 2013 for the Tribe was 67.0. As well as Hill did with inherited runners, his 65.9 BER shows how much trouble he got into throughout this past season. In theory, a lefty specialist should have a high BER, because he only faces a hitter or two before being pulled. Randy Choate (76.6 BER in 2013) comes to mind.

How did Cleveland compare as a team to other American League bullpens?

Here are the 2013 BER team rankings:

1. KC 75.5
2. TEX 73.9
3. MIN 73.8
4. TOR 73.5
5. BAL 73.4
6. TB 73.3
7. OAK 72.7
8. NYY 72.1
9. BOS 71.8
10. CLE 71.7
11. CWS 71.5
12. DET 71.4
13. LAA 71.3
14. SEA 70.2
15. HOU 68.9

You’ll find that the league WHIP rankings come close to how BER shakes out for the American League. You could also run BER for a starting pitcher, or for a team’s pitching staff as a whole, but my goal here was to limit it to relievers. I wanted something to throw lefty specialists, closers, middle men, long men and other bullpen arms together with one stat to show the efficiency of their work. For a starting pitching, given the high volume of innings, the BER scale would likely include slightly lower percentages to gauge success. For example, Clayton Kershaw was at 79.4 percent this past season.

What does this mean for the Indians’ bullpen for 2014? It could mean that the back end will be fine in the hands of guys like Allen, Shaw and Rzepczynski, if Smith and Albers leave via free agency. It also shows how re-signing Smith and/or Albers has the potential to help stabilize things, and that improving the lefty relief options should be a priority. If Cleveland is in the market for a new closer (Perez isn’t a lock to return, or regain that role), it’s easy to run the candidates’ BER to see if it’s the kind of efficiency needed in the ninth inning.

Feel free to provide feedback. No stat is without its flaws.

UPDATE: A few readers have pointed out that this stat is essentially 1 minus on-base percentage against. That’s true and I’m not claiming to have reinvented the wheel here. It is a slight variation of that concept, and is simply a different way to look at it. Taking ROE and IBB into account changes the result by a small margin, but enough to arguably be deemed significant, especially in certain cases (such as the Shaw example given above).



Ber stats concept vy interesting, but you forgot to say how much difference is statistically significant. Stats, polls etc are useless without this measure

Very interesting — extremely interesting using just your numbers where Boston “shakes out” on the list. Just out of curiosity — were you a math/stats major in another life?? Yes, I understand stats are VERY important in baseball. Thanks for the info. I enjoy your posts/emails.

Hi Tom,Great question. It would help to know which theme you pheaucsrd and of course what customizations you are looking to make. In addition to this comment I’m sending you an e-mail.In order to fully answer your question we’ll need to ask each other some questions.WordPress Themes can be endlessly modified, so your question is not specific enough. As for pricing, I prefer not to list my hourly rate on the site, but will share it with you when we converse via e-mail or phone. The pricing for modifications will depend on whether you want me to do the work for you or if you would like me to teach you how to perform the changes yourself.Thank you for the inquiry.

PS: Did you figure the stats out for the NL — wondering where the Cardinals rank.

Dolni ,skapani,mrasni,prostazi y idioti,jestoki uibizi!Sto za lajlivo opravdanie?Znachi dobrovolzite sa vi vinovni,ustroili sa vi kapan?V ada da gorite,decata vi da izmrat,zialoto vi seme chumata da gi ubie!Nima da se izviniavam za dumite si,zashtoto te sa otpraveni kam xora ,koito ne zaslujavat da jiveiat i da ostaviat pokolenie na tozi sviat!Kakvo stana,izplashix te li se,ne vi xaresva che zial sviat vidia che za nishto drugo ne vi biva,che ste prosto bokluzi,ubiizi,xora koito sa rodeni po pogreshka?Niamte li savest,niamate li strax ot vashiat Allah ?V sveshtenata vi kniga Korana ,kakto i v BIBLIATA se kazva da ne ubivame,no kakto vijdam vas ne vi puka za jivota !Mrazia vi,vnushavate mi otvrashtenie ,povrashta mi se ot vas!Kak shte obiasnite snimkite sas schupenata cheliust na kuchenzeto,tezi snimki na koito se vijdat trupovete na jivotni v nailonovi torbi i xvarleni na bokluka,mizeriata v koiato tezi bezzashtitni sashtestva jiveiat,manipulaziite ,koito ste izvarshvali bez obezboliavashti y prichiniavaiki neveroiatna bolka na kuchetata?Mrasnite kletki v koito sa prinudeni da jiveiat bednite sashtestva prilichat na konzlager Nima iskate da kajete, che che vsichki snimki i videota sa prosto fantastichni kolaji ili specialni efekti,za da vi obviniat v nechoveshko otnoshenie ?Shte vi kaja samo edno neshto:Nie zashtitnizite na jivotnite ,nie koito gi obichame ,Nie koito se borim za texnite prava ,Nie igraem po pravilata,nie ne sme vie ,nie ne se kriem,nie pokazvame istinata takava kakvato e! I SEGA SHTE VI OBESHTAIA NESHTO .AZ NE GOVORIA TURSKI,NO VI OBESHTAVAM CHE SHTE NAMERAI XORA ,KOITO GO GOVORIAT!Kalna vi se v jivota si,che shte zapochna da agitiram vsichki vashi sanarodnizi,xorata jiveeshti v Istanbul,da ne glasuvat ,na izborite koito nablijavat,za vas,za xorata ot obshtinata!Kak shte go napravia.?, Facebook e neogranichen,tuk ima xora ot zial sviat ,a Takiva ,koito jiveiat v istanbul sa mnogo!NEKA DA VIDIM DALI XORATA TAM SHTE IZBERAT DA GI UPRAVLIAVA T UBIIZI ILI SHTE ISKAT NIAKOI ,KOITO DA SI IZPALNIAVAT ZADALJENIATA I OBESHTANIATA !

Iskam da popitam sled kato poltinpye uvedomlenieto i go predstavq v Az ima li veroqtnost da ne mi go priemat zastoto e za distancionna forma i da me nakarat da si tyrsq drug dostavchik s pretekst , che za momenta e sprqna distancionnata forma na obuchenie ? Kato go poltinpye uvedomlenieto dati pi6ite li na zapo4vane na kursa ,tyi kato vaucheri za momenta za distancionna forma ne se izdavat i eventualno kakva e procedurata za sled tova ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: